Judge denies racial bias lawsuit filed by three Everett police officers

EVERETT — A federal judge has tossed out a lawsuit filed against Everett by three police officers who alleged they were denied promotions based on their race and subjected to a hostile work environment when they complained.

U.S. District Court Judge Richard Jones issued his decision earlier this month. The city argued that the officers failed to provide enough evidence to support their claims and to move forward with a trial.

“There is not a shred of evidence that the City of Everett has ever treated any of the plaintiffs differently because of their race. They weren’t. Instead, what is happening here is that the plaintiffs are disappointed that they did not receive promotions they sought,” the city’s attorney, James Sanders, wrote in court papers.

The lawsuit was filed on behalf of Sgt. Manuel Garcia, former Sgt. Richard Wolfington and officer Sherman Mah.

Garcia is the first Hispanic and bilingual officer in the city. He started in 1988 and became a sergeant in 2002. Mah is Chinese-American and has been with Everett since 1995. Wolfington is Native American and claimed he was forced to quit in 2013 after 20 years with the department.

The lawsuit alleged that city leaders knew the men were being mistreated but failed to take any action.

Along with the city, Capt. David Fudge and former Police Chief Kathy Atwood were named as defendants in the lawsuit.

“The City of Everett works hard to ensure that all of our employees are treated fairly and in accordance with the law, and Judge Jones’ ruling is a nice confirmation of all the hard work we have done to maintain a diverse workplace where everyone is judged on their merits,” spokeswoman Meghan Pembroke said Wednesday.

The lawsuit was filed in January 2014 in U.S. District Court in Seattle. Since then lawyers have deposed numerous police officers, including current Chief Dan Templeman, Atwood and Fudge.

Garcia claimed he was demoted from lieutenant after his six-month probation period because of unreasonable expectations. He said Fudge demanded more from him than from white lieutenants. He claimed he was the only officer in decades to be demoted immediately after the probationary period. He alleged white officers were given extensions or a change in supervisors.

The judge concluded that the city provided legitimate reasons why Garcia was demoted, including missing deadlines and not responding to email from his supervisors.

Garcia, on the other hand, failed to identify examples of discrimination related to his demotion.

“The absence of this type of specific evidence is fatal to his claim,” Jones wrote.

The sergeant’s opinion that his performance was satisfactory didn’t meet the legal standards to go forward with a trial, the judge wrote.

Evaluations show that Garcia was a strong candidate for promotion, and “there is no question that Mr. Garcia was and continues to be a valuable public servant,” Jones wrote.

The court said Fudge could have done more to mentor Garcia and the department could have used better methods to assist Garcia.

The city admitted that Garcia has strong community relations skills and his outreach efforts have led to a better police department.

“The court wholeheartedly agrees,” Jones wrote. “Unfortunately, the court does not sit as a super personnel department and cannot dictate the department’s decisions.”

The judge also found that city provided legitimate reasons why Mah wasn’t promoted to sergeant. Jones also concluded that the city wasn’t required to promote Mah under civil service rules. They police chief has discretion to chose one of the three top ranked candidates.

Wolfington failed to provide evidence that his working conditions were intolerable when he left in 2013, Jones wrote. The lawsuit alleged that Fudge retaliated against Wolfington when he reported that Fudge was in an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate female officer.

The judge concluded that Wolfington failed to provide proof that Fudge knew about Wolfington’s report. The judge also found that Wolfington failed to show that he was skipped over for promotions because of his race. Atwood, the former chief, testified that she didn’t know he was Native American. Wolfington didn’t provide any evidence to contradict her testimony, the judge wrote.

Bellevue attorney Benjamin Compton, of Vreeland Law, said Wednesday that his clients are considering whether to appeal the decision. Both Garcia and Mah are now assigned to patrol.

The court’s opinion that the officers cannot prove discrimination doesn’t change the fact that the officers weren’t promoted despite their experience, qualifications and rankings on civil service evaluations, Compton and lead attorney Victoria Vreeland wrote in a statement to The Herald.

“Discrimination may be hard to actually prove even when we see and feel it. Our clients have seen and felt it at the Everett Police Department,” they wrote.

The lawyers said their clients should be commended for making the issue public. It showed there were few police officers in leadership positions who “actually look like the diverse public they are charged with protecting,” the lawyers wrote.

The city’s lawyers have asked the judge to award them about $10,500 to cover the costs of depositions.

Diana Hefley: 425-339-3463; hefley@heraldnet.com. Twitter: @dianahefley.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

A firefighter stands in silence before a panel bearing the names of L. John Regelbrugge and Kris Regelbrugge during the ten-year remembrance of the Oso landslide on Friday, March 22, 2024, at the Oso Landslide Memorial in Oso, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘Flood of emotions’ as Oso Landslide Memorial opens on 10th anniversary

Friends, family and first responders held a moment of silence at 10:37 a.m. at the new 2-acre memorial off Highway 530.

Julie Petersen poses for a photo with images of her sister Christina Jefferds and Jefferds’ grand daughter Sanoah Violet Huestis next to a memorial for Sanoah at her home on March 20, 2024 in Arlington, Washington. Peterson wears her sister’s favorite color and one of her bangles. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
‘It just all came down’: An oral history of the Oso mudslide

Ten years later, The Daily Herald spoke with dozens of people — first responders, family, survivors — touched by the deadliest slide in U.S. history.

Victims of the Oso mudslide on March 22, 2014. (Courtesy photos)
Remembering the 43 lives lost in the Oso mudslide

The slide wiped out a neighborhood along Highway 530 in 2014. “Even though you feel like you’re alone in your grief, you’re really not.”

Director Lucia Schmit, right, and Deputy Director Dara Salmon inside the Snohomish County Department of Emergency Management on Friday, March 8, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
How Oso slide changed local emergency response ‘on virtually every level’

“In a decade, we have just really, really advanced,” through hard-earned lessons applied to the pandemic, floods and opioids.

Ron and Gail Thompson at their home on Monday, March 4, 2024 in Oso, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
In shadow of scarred Oso hillside, mudslide’s wounds still feel fresh

Locals reflected on living with grief and finding meaning in the wake of a catastrophe “nothing like you can ever imagine” in 2014.

Rep. Suzan DelBene, left, introduces Xichitl Torres Small, center, Undersecretary for Rural Development with the U.S. Department of Agriculture during a talk at Thomas Family Farms on Monday, April 3, 2023, in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Under new federal program, Washingtonians can file taxes for free

At a press conference Wednesday, U.S. Rep. Suzan DelBene called the Direct File program safe, easy and secure.

Former Snohomish County sheriff’s deputy Jeremie Zeller appears in court for sentencing on multiple counts of misdemeanor theft Wednesday, March 27, 2024, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Ex-sheriff’s deputy sentenced to 1 week of jail time for hardware theft

Jeremie Zeller, 47, stole merchandise from Home Depot in south Everett, where he worked overtime as a security guard.

Everett
11 months later, Lake Stevens man charged in fatal Casino Road shooting

Malik Fulson is accused of shooting Joseph Haderlie to death in the parking lot at the Crystal Springs Apartments last April.

T.J. Peters testifies during the murder trial of Alan Dean at the Snohomish County Courthouse on Tuesday, March 26, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Bothell cold case trial now in jury’s hands

In court this week, the ex-boyfriend of Melissa Lee denied any role in her death. The defendant, Alan Dean, didn’t testify.

A speed camera facing west along 220th Street Southwest on Tuesday, Nov. 21, 2023 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
New Washington law will allow traffic cams on more city, county roads

The move, led by a Snohomish County Democrat, comes as roadway deaths in the state have hit historic highs.

Mrs. Hildenbrand runs through a spelling exercise with her first grade class on the classroom’s Boxlight interactive display board funded by a pervious tech levy on Tuesday, March 19, 2024 in Marysville, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lakewood School District’s new levy pitch: This time, it won’t raise taxes

After two levies failed, the district went back to the drawing board, with one levy that would increase taxes and another that would not.

Alex Hanson looks over sections of the Herald and sets the ink on Wednesday, March 30, 2022 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Black Press, publisher of Everett’s Daily Herald, is sold

The new owners include two Canadian private investment firms and a media company based in the southern United States.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.